Update on Bhattarai v. Nielsen

This latest FRN continues DHS’ compliance with the stay of proceedings order and court approval of the parties’ stipulation in Bhattarai et al. v. Nielsen et al., No. 19-cv-731 (N.D. Cal. March 12, 2019). Under the court’s order, USCIS will continue TPS and extend appropriate TPS-related documentation (Forms I-766, Employment Authorization Documents (EADs); Forms I-797, Notice of Action; and Forms I-94, Arrival/Departure Record) for eligible beneficiaries of TPS for Honduras and TPS for Nepal while the preliminary injunction in Ramos et al. v. Nielsen et al., 336 F.Supp. 3d 1075 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 3, 2018), vacated but reh’g en banc requested 975 F.3d 872 (9th Cir., Sept. 14, 2020) remains in effect. A 3-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated the district court’s injunction in Ramos on Sept. 14, 2020. However, pending a decision on the plaintiffs’ petition for further review before the entire 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, the appellate court has not issued its directive to the district court to make that ruling effective. Due to the similar issues raised in the Bhattarai case, the district court has stayed proceedings pending the outcome of the government’s appeal in Ramos.

While the Bhattarai court order is effective, DHS will not terminate the TPS designations for Honduras or Nepal or the TPS for an individual beneficiaries provided that a beneficiary’s TPS is not withdrawn under INA section 244(c)(3) or 8 CFR 244.14 because of individual ineligibility.

Current Status

The court order adopting the parties’ joint stipulation to stay proceedings is currently in effect. As a result of this order, pending the resolution of the appeal in Ramos, the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal remain in effect. On Nov. 10, 2022, DHS announced an FRN for eligible, affected beneficiaries of TPS for Honduras and Nepal that continues TPS and automatically extends the validity of specified TPS-related documents for the affected beneficiaries through June 30, 2024.

While the Bhattarai district court order approving the parties’ stipulation and staying proceedings remains in effect, TPS beneficiaries under the designations for Honduras and Nepal will maintain their status, provided they continue to meet all the individual requirements for TPS eligibility found in INA section 244(c) and 8 CFR 244, as well as in the instructions for Form I-821, Application for Temporary Protected Status.

If the Bhattarai court order staying district court proceedings continues in effect beyond June 30, 2024, DHS will continue to issue notices that will automatically extend TPS-related documentation for all affected, eligible beneficiaries under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal, or consistent with any other order of the court.

In Case of Reversal

If the Ramos appellate court issues its directive to the district court to vacate the preliminary injunction and the Bhattarai court also lifts its order staying proceedings, then the terminations of the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal will take effect, unless the final Bhattarai court order places other limitations on the terminations or other DHS action regarding Nepal’s or Honduras’ TPS designations have occurred.

Should the terminations of TPS for Nepal and/or Honduras be permitted to occur, neither termination will be effective any earlier than 365 days from the date the Bhattarai order lifting the stay of proceedings occurs in order to allow for an orderly transition period. If one or more of the terminations becomes effective, USCIS will inform TPS beneficiaries when the transition period will begin. The transition period will provide time for current TPS beneficiaries who do not have another lawful immigration status or authorization to remain in the United States to leave the United States, or they will be subject to removal.

Demonstrating Temporary Protected Status

As evidence of valid TPS, eligible beneficiaries under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal may show their TPS-related documents, which have been specified in the Nov. 2022 FRN as having been automatically extended through June 30, 2024, along with that FRN.

DHS is automatically extending the validity periods of the following Forms I-94 and Forms I-797, Notice of Action (Approval Notice), previously issued to eligible beneficiaries granted TPS under the designations for Honduras and Nepal:

However, the extension of these validity periods applies only if the eligible TPS beneficiary properly filed for TPS re-registration during 1 of the most recent DHS-announced registration periods for Honduras: May 16-July 15, 2016; Dec. 15, 2017-Feb. 13, 2018; or June 5-Aug. 6, 2018, or for Nepal: Oct. 26–Dec. 27, 2016, or May 22–July 23, 2018, or has a re-registration application that remains pending.

Current End Date

TPS beneficiaries under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal will maintain valid TPS in the United States as long as the Bhattarai court order, or any superseding court order, prevents DHS from implementing and enforcing the TPS termination determinations, provided that each TPS beneficiary under these designations maintains their individual eligibility for TPS. Some TPS beneficiaries may also have other valid immigration status or authorization to remain in the United States that may continue once TPS for their country ends. If a court order permits the termination of TPS for any country, USCIS will issue an FRN, if warranted, and update its website to inform beneficiaries of the termination date and any applicable orderly transition period.

Re-Registration

TPS beneficiaries under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal will maintain valid TPS in the United States as long as the Bhattarai court order, or any superseding court order, prevents DHS from implementing and enforcing the TPS termination determinations, provided that each TPS beneficiary under these designations maintains their individual eligibility for TPS. Some TPS beneficiaries may also have other valid immigration status or authorization to remain in the United States that may continue once TPS for their country ends. If a court order permits the termination of TPS for any country, USCIS will issue an FRN, if warranted, and update its website to inform beneficiaries of the termination date and any applicable orderly transition period.

Individuals who held TPS prior to the new Honduras extension and who wish to ensure that they maintain TPS if the Ramos injunction ends, provided that they remain eligible for TPS, are encouraged to submit their applications for TPS following the instructions in the extension of Honduras for TPS FRN 88 FR 40304 . Failure to submit an application under the new extension of Honduras, however, does not affect the continuation of the validity of the TPS and TPS documents through June 30, 2024 if the individual was granted TPS under the 1999 designation for Honduras that the court has continued as long as the injunction exists.

Individuals who held TPS prior to the new Nepal extension and who wish to ensure that they maintain TPS if the Ramos injunction ends, provided that they remain eligible for TPS, are encouraged to submit their applications for TPS following the instructions in the extension of Nepal for TPS FRN 88 FR 40317. Failure to submit an application under the new extension of Nepal, however, does not affect the continuation of the validity of the TPS and TPS documents through June 30, 2024 if the individual was granted TPS under the 2015 designation for Nepal that the court has continued as long as the injunction exists.

Beneficiaries who did not re-register during any of these periods may still file Form I-821, Application for Temporary Protected Status, but must demonstrate “good cause” for failing to re-register on time, as required by law. See INA, section 244(c)(3)(C).

Late re-registrants must submit a letter describing all of their reasons for failing to file on time in accordance with the most recently announced re-registration procedures in the FRN for their TPS-designated country.

If you re-registered outside of the re-registration period because DHS announced the termination of TPS for your country, you should explain how that announcement affected you, including how the termination decisions affected your failure to re-register. USCIS may consider this explanation for purposes of meeting the “good cause” exception for failing to re-register on time. However, if the announcement of the TPS termination did not cause you to file late, you should not include it as a reason. Applicants must be truthful in explaining their reasons.

Biometrics

TPS beneficiaries who are age 14 or older and who did not file for re-registration under the re-registration procedures announced during at least 1 of the periods listed above for their country must submit biometrics when they file a late re-registration application. USCIS will send the individual a scheduling notice for biometrics collection, if required. USCIS may also send a separate biometrics scheduling notice to a TPS beneficiary who has properly re-registered, but who later filed a Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization, for an EAD.

Employment Authorization Documents

In the Nov. 2022 FRN, DHS announced the automatic extension of EADs for TPS beneficiaries under the designations of Honduras and Nepal through June 30, 2024, with the category codes “A-12” or “C-19” and 1 of the expiration dates shown below:

TPS beneficiaries with EADs that are auto-extended do not need to apply for a new EAD, but they may if they choose to do so. If they file for a new EAD, they must pay the Form I-765 application fee or request a fee waiver. Additionally, beneficiaries of TPS Honduras and TPS Nepal who have EAD and re-registration applications pending will receive an EAD with a validity date through June 30, 2024, if USCIS approves their re-registration and EAD applications.

If DHS publishes a subsequent FRN before June 30, 2024, that FRN will either extend TPS-related documents from June 30, 2024, or provide appropriate procedures for obtaining renewed TPS documentation for all affected eligible beneficiaries under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal.

Any eligible beneficiary under the TPS designations for Honduras and Nepal who does not possess an EAD that is automatically extended in the FRN, or who wishes to apply for a new EAD, despite having an older EAD that is automatically extended under the FRN, may file Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization, with the appropriate fee or fee waiver request. If USCIS approves the application, it will issue an EAD with a June 30, 2024, expiration date.

If you would like to request a fee waiver, complete Form I-912, Request for Fee Waiver, and submit it with your Form I-765.

Establishing Employment Eligibility

TPS beneficiaries may present their unexpired EADs or facially expired EADs that have been automatically extended through June 30, 2024, as specified in the Nov. 2022 FRN to their employer as evidence of employment eligibility and identity when completing Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification. Employees may show their employer this FRN, which provides instructions on how employers must complete Form I-9 and indicates that their facially expired EAD has been automatically extended through June 30, 2024. As also noted in the FRN and on the USCIS I-9 Central webpage, an individual may satisfy Form I-9 requirements for employment eligibility verification with any of the types of acceptable documents, or combination of documents, described on Form I-9.

Form I-9 is mandatory for all employment in the United States, but its requirements do not apply until an employer actually hires an individual. Employees may present any documentation from the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents to their employer to show identity and employment eligibility. For purposes of Form I-9, an unexpired EAD or an EAD with a validity period that is auto-extended by the FRN are acceptable to prove both identity and eligibility to work. 

Employers can learn more about completing Form I-9 by visiting I-9 Central or calling the I-9 Contact Center:

• For Employers: 888-464-4218
• For Employees: 888-897-7781
• TTY: 877-875-6028

Discrimination in Employment Verification

Employees can report an employer who rejects acceptable documents for I-9 purposes or who refuses to accept an auto-extended EAD, and refer any discrimination-related questions, to the Immigrant and Employee Rights Section in the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division:

• For Employees: 800-255-7688
• For Employers: 800-255-8155
• TTY: 202-616-5525 or 800-237-2515

Demonstrating Status to State Agencies

TPS beneficiaries who need to demonstrate their continued lawful status to obtain a driver’s license or other benefit to a state or local agency that uses USCIS’ Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) Program must have an Alien Number or I-94 number to be verified through SAVE. These numbers can be found on various immigration documents beneficiaries may have received regarding their TPS.

DHS issues the following documents that satisfy this requirement:

• Form I-797, Notice of Action, approval notice for I-821, Application for Temporary Protected Status, has an A-Number;
• Form I-765, Employment Authorization Document (EAD). EADs issued to TPS recipients will indicate a category of A12 or C19 and have an A-Number;
• Form I-512, Authorization for Parole of an Alien into the United States, has an A-Number. This form is issued to TPS beneficiaries who request travel authorization and who are allowed to travel outside the United States and return if authorized at the port of entry by Customs and Border Protection;
• Form I-512T, Authorization for Travel by a Noncitizen to the United States; and
• Form I-94 Arrival/Departure Record, has an I-94 number.

Beneficiaries may also have a final order from the Executive Office of Immigration Review granting TPS that may have either an A-Number or an I-94 number.

For further information, see our webpage on SAVE for Benefit Applicants.

If DHS has published an FRN announcing the automatic extension of certain TPS-related documents, SAVE advises TPS beneficiaries to show the state or local agency a copy of the FRN documenting such extension with their most recently issued immigration document.

While SAVE can verify when an individual has TPS, each agency’s procedures govern whether they will accept an auto-extended TPS-related document. You should present the agency with a copy of the relevant FRN showing the extension of TPS-related documents in addition to your recent TPS-related document with your A-Number or I-94 number. You should explain that SAVE will be able to verify the continuation of your TPS. You should ask the agency to initiate a SAVE query with your information and follow through with additional verification steps, if necessary, to get a final SAVE response confirming TPS. You can also ask the agency to look for SAVE notices or contact SAVE if they have any questions about your immigration status or auto-extension of TPS-related documents.